Meeting minutes
W3C ODRL workshop
Beatriz: 1 hour session at TPAC in Dublin, not attending in-person, we are discussing deliverables of the working group. There is interest to standardise the DPV-ODRL profile which should be of interest to this group.
Beatriz: ODRL CG started a profile for AI. A lot of the proposed stuff seems to already be in the DPV AI and AI Act extensions. So there may be no need for AI profile if the DPV-ODRL profile already provides this concepts.
ODRL AI profile https://
Beatriz: There are also talks about ODRL profile for Data Spaces. There was supposed to be a paper about this but it hasn't been published yet. Also no HTML specification for this to look at. Expected that what will be in it will be covered already in DPV.
Beatriz: Someone from Fraunhofer was also using DPV to map requirements from the GDPR and they were not aware of the GDPR extension or other stuff apart from the core vocab.
Harsh: How are they missing the other extensions as we changed the HTML and it is mentioned in the Primer and Github Readme. So what is it that they do that does not expose these other works?
Beatriz: They maybe didn't look. They also didn't seem to know about the CG or the meetings. They said they will join the CG. They also seem to be modelling DGA, AI Act ,etc.
v2.4 delays/revised timeline
Harsh: work going slowly, remaining part is changelog -- but checking whether to publish as we're delayed by a month
Beatriz: yes, should publish as v2.4
fixes for OWL HTML in v2.2 and v2.3
Beatriz: w3c-cg/
Harsh: HTML files are missing - seems to be a regression since v2.2 with v2.3 and v2.4 also missing HTML files for owL. We will add a HTML file listing concepts in OWL with link to the main spec for documentation. Confirming we should also do the same for v2.2 and v2.3 without version changes.
accepted to implement
fix parent of Charity (Org)
Harsh: w3c-cg/
Beatriz: Concept for Charity has no parent. It has type legal entity but no non-profit or organisation. Could be pushed to v2.5.
ACTION: Add parent Non-Profit for dpv:Charity for v2.5
w3c github redirect error
Beatriz: w3c-cg/
Harsh: Issue where previous github links do not migrate for specific files. No fixes known.
ACTION: Let w3c cg team know about redirection error
Data Act proposal
Harsh: w3c-cg/
Harsh: We already had said Data Act is in scope so this would be creating and adding to that extension for v2.5
Beatriz: Marlin and I would also be looking at Data Act so we would look at this in September-December.
Marlin: Will speak with Sheyla and others about participating and joining DPVCG.
AOB
GDPR Active/Passive Rights
Gabriela: In DPV, we have Active and Passive Rights, but I could not find how these concepts are used in the DPV. I'm currently finding Active/Passive rights in the GDPR, and want to use DPV. Is the idea to look at these concepts as informative or they should be more proactive e.g. if it triggers an obligation?
Beatriz: The concept would have come from my thesis.
Harsh: We were discussing the rights exercise spec at that point, which would have been applicable only for active rights. And then we forgot about it I guess.
ACTION: Gabriela to open an issue proposing modelling of rights as active/passive in laws, starting with GDPR rights for v2.5
Harsh: Next Meeting
… In 2 weeks on 19th August